Best of Nantucket, a Reservation & Destination Management Company located on Nantucket Island, established in 1995 and located at 35 Old South Road, Nantucket. Offering island visitors the highest level of customer service. Our knowledge and local expertise are unsurpassed, truly the Best. Let us help you with your plans for your first or twentieth trip to Nantucket.

Sheila O’Brien Egan, President & Owner

Sheila O’Brien Egan, President & Owner, 

moved to Nantucket in October 1983. In April of 1995 Sheila formed the Best of Nantucket to accommodate individual and group reservation services for Nantucket.

With her client-centered philosophy, travel expertise, destination knowledge and vendor relationships her business has grown and prospered in a very competitive environment. She attributes the success of her business to her practice of placing the clients’ needs first and exceeding their expectations for service, recommendations, and travel experience and destination knowledge.

Sheila enjoys working directly with clients from the planning stages to the client’s evaluation of their travel experience.

Give Sheila a call at 508-228-1069 or email at (attention Sheila) for your vacation and she will make sure you have the absolute Best Nantucket experience.

Judy Wodynski, Best of Nantucket On-Island Wedding & Group Event Manager

Judy Wodynski joined the Best of Nantucket Team in 2016 and has assisted hundreds of visitors to the island find the right accommodations for their stay. She began coming to Nantucket in 1978 and moved to the island permanently in 2004. With such a long history on-island, she has an extensive knowledge of the island and all that it offers.

Judy and her team tour most of the Nantucket inns and hotels annually and review almost every category of rooms at more than 20 of the island’s historic inns, hotels and luxury resorts. Their familiarity with Nantucket accommodations enables them to find the best fit for anyone coming to this iconic island. From families to solo adventures, wedding parties to leisure stays, Judy is delighted to assist each traveler in finding the right accommodations to enjoy their stay on Nantucket.

You can reach her by calling, 508-228-1069, or email her at